Question about Right breed for me?

Hi, I have a house that is about 3000 sq ft. And a very small kind of garden. And i'm looking forward to get a puppy. I could take it for walk/jog for 1hour a day if needed. There is no fincial problem. We don't like a dog that sheds too much and We want our puppy to be fairly easy to train and be nice to my daughter who is 8years old.



So, with my research, I came up with



American Bulldog

Labordor Retriever

German Shepard

English Bulldog







Please help me which one I should get and why. You could tell me a different breed to also. And please dont tell me to go to a shelter cause I been to many of them already!

Thank you

Question about Right breed for me?
With only one hour of exercise a day, the Bulldog is your best bet. American Bulls, and Labs are highly energetic breeds, whereas bulldogs have minimal exercise requirements and will do well in a small garden. They are known to be great with kids, but be sure to do some research before buying. They are expensive to obtain, and are prone to respitory and skin problems....a bit of maintenence.
Reply:I'll vote for a

1. German Shepard

2. Labrador Retriever (Golden)





Both will need walking and I believe both are easy to train.
Reply:I went to tons of shelters in my city and all the puppies are snatched up right away, so my huby and I went through a breeder. I'd probably get a lab since they're stereotypically the best family dogs out of those you listed. sheps can have some bad hip problems and bulldogs can have breathing and eye problems. labs are shorthaired and shed quite a bit, but with regular brushing that can be solved. you would need to walk them at least 3 times a week, as they can get lazy and complacent. best of luck!
Reply:I have owned each of these dogs with the exception of the English Bulldog (due to potential medical issues already listed).



I would have to go with the American Bulldog. I currently have two and couldn't imagine going back to one of the other breeds you listed. My ABD's have been incredibly easy to train and I have found with a 30 minute walk or a good hard game of fetch in the morning and another in the evening, they are willing and able to relax in their kennels or with me watching a movie. I also throw in an hour at the dog park or playing in the creek (summertime) 3-4 times a week. They love people, especially children, although they sometimes forget that they aren't lap dogs.



When you choose your puppy, pay attention to the temperament and the size. Each dog is definitely an individual. Kyra, my female is 2 now, 76 lbs, a little shy at first, and loves to run. Glacier, my pup, is 92 lbs at 8 months old, never met a stranger, and would rather cuddle on the couch than play. Figure out what will fit into your lifestyle the best and make sure you make a good choice. You won't regret it.
Reply:american bulldog, a hearty breed with proper training and family involvement can be a good choice,



Labrador are a popular breed and you should do considerable research into the choice here.



German shepards(GSD) are also versatile dogs,

with proper training and family involvement



the english buldog is the one to watch out for since they are prone to many mediccal problems and even with a good back ground check you could be into higher medical bills (i have yet to see one which does not have medical problems)



Bottom line is that the whole family should be involved with the care of the dog you choose. so get them invloved in the choice they will be more likely to help if they have a choice.



an hour a day exersize may not be enough for most of the breeds you have listed. and the english bull dog is the only one that would do Ok with this



you should consider taking a training class with waht ever breed you choose, and have each member of the family be involved.
Reply:German Shepard

i love this kind of dog there easy to train and great for kids and pets??????
Reply:What ever you get make sure that you get it from a shelter. Try www.petfinder.com
Reply:Labordor Retriever is going to be more Kid Friendly, where the German Shepard is more of a gaurd dog... or you can try a small dog like a Yorkie..
Reply:well, you said you don't like dogs that shed a lot, so get a poodle or a mini schnauzer, maltese, those are breeds that don't shed.
Reply:labs are smart and easy to train but they have a lot of energy and chew tons as puppies. bulldogs are expensive and are outlawed in some places but i love them. there are a lot of misconceptions about them and you may have trouble when people come over because they may want you to put him up while they're there. i'd go with the german shepard. they are big and might be hard to control for and 8 year old (actually all of them are.) but they are brilliant and one of my favorite breeds. i'd go with a smaller breed because of space and age of child. jack russels are amazing but they have tons of energy and they can get out of practically any enclosure. they are also stubborn and independent. i'd go with a smallish mutt or yorkie/ shih'tzu type dog.
Reply:This question seems to come up almost every week...



Letting someone else pick your dog for you is like letting someone pick out a girlfriend for you...its absurd!



As they say opinions are like a**holes, everybody has one and they all stink!



yahoo group: upstateamericanbulldoggers
Reply:i would suggest english bulldog, if you are keeping it in the house the smaller breed would be easier.
Reply:Bulldogs are typically more stubborn and less willing to please than other breeds of dogs, and therefore aren't always the easiest to train.



In my experience, German Shepherds and Labradors shed a lot and both need quite a bit of exercise to be happy, balanced dogs. German Shepherds aren't always the easiest to train, either, unless you're willing to step into the role of Alpha or Pack Leader. If you're willing to exercise a German Shepherd and be its leader, they can be quite obedient, but as I said, they aren't the lowest shedders and can actually shed quite a bit. I believe they shed year round as well. Labrador puppies also aren't always the easiest to train. They're full of energy and life and they don't always particularly care what you want to tell them. When they get older they tend to be more obedient, but as young puppies they're full of life and energy so it's an entirely different story.



Honestly, I wouldn't suggest any of the breeds of dogs you have listed with that set of requirements.



Some dogs I might suggest:



Poodles (particularly standard poodles if you want a larger dog)

A smaller breed of dog



Poodles are very willing to please, very obedient, and very intelligent. They aren't high energy and would be sufficiently exercised with an hour of exercise a day. They don't shed, though you do need to groom them. They get along very well with children and other dogs and animals. Considering your requirements, they sound like a nice match. My standard poodle puppies are also very easy to train and my four month old puppy knows many tricks and commands already.
Reply:We have had great success with Jack Russell terriers. They are a big dog in a small package.

True, they can be hyper, but tend to mirror the behavior that they are around.( Playful around play, restful if at rest).

Very loyal and loving.



Ginger-
Reply:Sorry but i have to say you need a smaller breed they take less time to walk some are easier to train leave a smaller mess behind can take a smaller dog more places than a big dog and the kids Love to be able to pick up and sit on sofa and have there pet with them. they cost less all the way around

BUT this will be your choice not mine. So good luck with the new Baby.
Reply:This dog isn't on your list but I would suggest a Boxer. They don't shed as much as some of the dogs on your list and they are amazing family dogs. They love children and will take the liberty to protect your children.



When I was 3, our female boxer saved me because I snuck out of the house and was trying to go swimming in the lake. I would have drowned if she didn't come after me.
Reply:Labrador retrievers are very trainable and eager to please, but shed much. Out of the group you've listed I'd say they are your best bet, especially if it is your first dog.

German shepherds are lovely, beautiful dogs, but you need to have more of an understanding of their instincts before you get one (as you should have an understanding with any dog, but especially working/protection breeds like the GSD).

Bulldogs are nice, sturdy, hardy little fellas, but need much socializing as they can be very reserved towards other dogs and strangers without it. not to mention many of them drool very much and need special attention to their eyes and wrinkles.



As with any breed, make sure you do good research on them first. Know the temperament and behaviour of the breed as well as what health problems to look for. Like I said, in my opinion, I'd stick with a lab despite the hair because they are well worth doing a little extra vacuuming. If you are getting one from a breeder, make sure you are acquainted with the parents of the puppies as it is likely that many of your dogs traits-both physical and beaviour-will be inherited from them.
Reply:I have always had Labradors. They are GREAT family dogs and very intelligent so they should be extremely easy to train! They do need plenty of exercise though, so if you have time try to do more than one hour a day, maybe on weekends go to a dog park/lake etc, and let it run!!
Reply:labrador retriever, they are among the easiest breeds to train, love kids, really gentles, and could easily run all day, but if at home, they do like to relax and have a bit of pampering, which i am sure your kids will provide, and bull dogs have a much larger % of attacks in the u.k. and german shepards need alot of exercise and a big garden and they do have a short temper. so i would go with labrador or labrador retriever
Reply:I say a German Shepherd...it is not German Shepard...obviously you have not done research...but still German Shepherd

rodeo buckle