Should I punish him??????

The other day, I caught my dog with 2 or his mates (also dogs) behind the garden shed smoking cigarettes, what punishment should I give him? (Ive told him never to smoke) he is sooo disobedient, he never listens to me anymore.

Should I punish him??????
Make him smoke a cigar in front of you. He'll be so sick he'll never smoke again
Reply:Definitely
Reply:When he never listen to you ,what difference punishment will make,try to tell him in nice way,may that helps you.
Reply:Take away his pack and give it to me. I'm out. =[
Reply:i'd eat em
Reply:Make him smoke a whole carton in front of you, that should take care of the problem.
Reply:Spank him
Reply:No punishment is necessary....patience will curb his nasty habits...give him love and support...and you, you get a life.
Reply:you don't have to punish him more, he'll die of lung cancer
Reply:I wouldn't. He sounds pretty smart. Do you know how hard it is to light a smoke without thumbs??

Neither of my dogs have not figured that out yet. One just eats the butts, the other growls, barks and digs the ground when you offer her one.

beauty eye